McGillicuddy's

84 Main Street, New Paltz, NY 12561

Passed · Mar 5, 2026 Directions
95
Excellent BiteKarma score 95 out of 100
How the BiteKarma score works

Each routine inspection starts at 100 and loses 7 points for every critical violation and 2 for every other one, half again as much when the same problem was cited at one of the two inspections before. A failed inspection counts as 69 at most. The score averages the five newest routine inspections, with the most recent counting most, and stays below 70 for 90 days after a fail unless the restaurant passes again. 90 and up is excellent, 80s good, 70s fair, and below 70 poor.

At a glance

  • Passed 6 of 6 graded inspections since 2024.
  • Last inspected Mar 5, 2026: passed with 1 violation.
  • No critical violations in the last two years.
  • Keeps coming up: Non food contact surfaces of equipment not clean, cited 3 times, plus 3 other repeat issues.

Inspection history 6 visits

  1. 2026
  2. Passed Mar 5

    Inspection

    1 violation
    • Minor Non food contact surfaces of equipment not clean
  3. Passed Feb 4

    Inspection

    3 violations
    • Minor Insects, rodents present
    • Minor Food contact surfaces not washed, rinsed and sanitized after each use and following any time of operations when contamination may have occurred
    • Minor Floors, walls, ceilings, not smooth, properly constructed, in disrepair, dirty surfaces
  4. 2025
  5. Passed Mar 26

    Inspection

    3 violations
    • Minor Non food contact surfaces of equipment not clean
    • Minor Handwashing facilities inaccessible, improperly located, dirty, in disrepair, improper fixtures, soap, and single service towels or hand drying devices missing
    • Minor Improper use and storage of clean, sanitized equipment and utensils
  6. Passed Feb 19

    Inspection

    4 violations
    • Minor Plumbing and sinks not properly sized, installed, maintained; equipment and floors not properly drained
    • Minor Non food contact surfaces of equipment not clean
    • Minor Non-food contact surfaces and equipment are improperly designed, constructed, installed, maintained (equipment not readily accessible for cleaning, surface not smooth finish)
    • Minor Floors, walls, ceilings, not smooth, properly constructed, in disrepair, dirty surfaces

Nearby

BiteKarma scores around McGillicuddy's, which is the dark pin. Zoom in to see the dots' scores, and tap a pin marked + to see everything at that address.

  1. 100 Huguenot Creamery 50 ft
  2. 99 Moonburger 100 ft
  3. 100 Starbucks 100 ft
  4. 93 Sideshow Kitchen & Bar 100 ft
  5. 91 P GS Restaurant 100 ft